Open Theism Discussion Board
  HomeLog InRegisterSearch the ForumHelp
   
Open Theism Discussion Board > Public Forums > Theological Q&A > (No Subject)
 
Forum Quick Jump
 
New Topic Post Reply Printable Version
54 posts in this thread.
Viewing Page :
 1  2  3 
[ << Previous Thread | Next Thread >> | Show Newest Post First ]

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 4/22/2003 5:48 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
I was reading what I consider to be a fairly modern approach to the question of women in ministry positions posted on the home page of Christus Victor Ministries and felt a need to question some of what I read.

Some of the statements are made from a position of incomplete knowledge, i.e. "But I don’t know of any church that would turn away a woman with a question and send her home to ask her husband." The Amish and Mennonites have done this very thing since the very early 1500's and the Waterland Mennonite connection to the General Baptists of England is well documented. This would mean the SBC has only continued with their historic position in rejecting women in a pastoral position and this action has nothing to do with fundamentalism.
quote:
In chapter 11 Paul says that when a woman prays or prophesies in church, she should have a veil on her head. But in order to pray or prophesy in church, a woman would have to be speaking. Apparently Paul was okay with women praying and prophesying in church as long as they are veiled. So what does this mean 3 chapters later when Paul says that it’s a disgrace for women to speak in church?
If Dr. C.C. Ryrie (Ryrie Study Bible) and Dr. S. Lewis Johnson (I Corinthians, Wycliffle Bible Commentary) are consulted, it would be noted that there isn't anything in I Corinthians 11 that would suggest a cultural application. The head covering is still applicable and there can be examples of praying and prophesying that do not include speaking. It should be obvious that praying is different from speaking, even though some people try to preach a sermon in their prayers. I Chronicles 25.1-7 tells us "who should prophesy with harps, with psalteries, and with cymbals:" and some of those "who" were the three daughters of Heman. In Exodus 15.20-21 we find this about the prophetess Miriam, "And Miriam the prophetess, the sister of Aaron, took a timbrel in her hand; and all the women went out after her with timbrels and with dances.
21 And Miriam answered them, Sing ye to the LORD, for he hath triumphed gloriously; the horse and his rider hath he thrown into the sea." " Answered them" is obviously the women mentioned in verse 20, not a group of men.

"Judges 4–5 tells the story of a remarkable woman named Deborah, who served as judge over all Israel and rallied the army of Israel to victory over the Canaanites." Samson was also a judge over Israel, but that certainly doesn't imply spiritual oversight. Judges 17.6 and 21.25 tell us, "every man did that which was right in his own eyes", because they had no king.

"1 Timothy 1:5 reveals that Timothy’s mother Eunice and his grandmother Lois passed their faith on to him." Is this anything other than what would be expected of and even commanded to any Jewish mother and grandmother? Deut. 6.7 "And thou shalt teach them diligently unto thy children, and shalt talk of them when thou sittest in thine house, and when thou walkest by the way, and when thou liest down, and when thou risest up."

"They did not make a clear distinction between prophets and preachers because both were responsible for speaking the word of God under the Holy Spirit’s anointing" This has already been shown to be thinking that may be confined to too narrow of a definition for prophesy. The pianist, organist and song leader are prophesying too!

"In 16:1–2, Paul refers to a woman named Phoebe as a deacon and describes her as a fellow laborer for the gospel." In actuality, Paul uses the feminine form (diakonon) of servant that is properly translated in the KJV. Otherwise, "Rulers" in Romans 13.3-4 who are servants/ministers (diakonos) would suddenly become deacons of the church. Ryrie in The Role of Women in the Church, Moody Press, 1970, addresses this matter and concludes Phoebe was not a deaconess. In reference to diakonos and etc. "It is the most general term used for all kinds of ministry, and in this general sense there is of course a male and female diaconate in the New Testament." (Ryrie, p 86) "Women workers, yes; women deacons, no." (Ryrie, p 91)

Even though I could continue with more examples, I think I have presented an ample amount to make the point without getting into the criteria of being the husband of one wife. I Cor 11.3 "But I would have you know, that the head of every man is Christ; and the head of the woman is the man; and the head of Christ is God."

Please don't think this has been a personal attack, since it certainly isn't intended that way.



Edited by - Paul5388 on 04/22/2003 10:54:48 PM
Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/25/2003 10:49 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Let's bump this up for reconsideration by those who may have missed it or ignored it the first time it was posted.
Back to Top
 

Tigress
Registered Member


Date Joined Feb 2003
Total Posts : 1252
 
   Posted 8/25/2003 10:58 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
1 Thessalonians 5:19 - "Quench not the Spirit."

Where God has given the spiritual gift of preaching, teaching, and prophesying, whether it be to a man or a woman, do not commit the sin of saying it is evil and not of God or His Will. Women preachers of the true Gospel wouldn't be able to preach at all without the ability given to them by the Holy Spirit. Who are you, Oh Man, to judge God and whom He chooses to do His work?


Tigress Tigress

"Name a shrub after me. Preferably one that's prickly and difficult to eradicate."

-Captain Jack Aubrey
"Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World"

Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/25/2003 11:02 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Tigress,

A woman can be a preacher to the younger women, but do you think He is going to contradict what He has written as qualifications for the office of elder/bishop or deacon?
Back to Top
 

Tigress
Registered Member


Date Joined Feb 2003
Total Posts : 1252
 
   Posted 8/25/2003 11:38 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
quote:
Originally posted by Paul5388

Tigress,

A woman can be a preacher to the younger women, but do you think He is going to contradict what He has written as qualifications for the office of elder/bishop or deacon?



God made it possible for both men and women to hold all of these offices. He gave both men and women equal giftings. If it weren't so, women wouldn't be as smart as they are. And they certainly wouldn't have these spiritual giftings to teach to all people. Don't you think that a woman could teach you something that no one else can? Don't you think that God can use women this way? Don't put God in a box. He won't fit.


Tigress Tigress

"Name a shrub after me. Preferably one that's prickly and difficult to eradicate."

-Captain Jack Aubrey
"Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World"

Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/25/2003 12:08 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Tigress,

I certainly don't put God in a box.

Let me tell you about my "baby" girl, who will be 30 in a couple of months. She has always been at home, under my care. She has never dated, not even once. She was home schooled since the 4th grade. We have home churched for the past 10 years and there have never been any men her age in attendance. The world, and most of the church, would say there isn't any way she will ever get married, because all of the modern procedures for obtaining a mate are being neglected/ignored/rejected. That's what you call putting God in a very little box! She has set a wedding date of Dec 27 to marry a young man from Dallas (which is 160 miles from here).

The moral of the story is, God can accomplish what He wants, whether it conforms to the world's standards or not. In fact, you might say His response to our standards/thinking is, "Man's thinking be stinking!"

Not only is there a moral to the story, but there is encouragement to be content no matter what state we are in and to wait upon the Lord and His timing.
Back to Top
 

Tigress
Registered Member


Date Joined Feb 2003
Total Posts : 1252
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 4:56 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
quote:
Originally posted by Paul5388

Tigress,

I certainly don't put God in a box.

Let me tell you about my "baby" girl, who will be 30 in a couple of months. She has always been at home, under my care. She has never dated, not even once. She was home schooled since the 4th grade. We have home churched for the past 10 years and there have never been any men her age in attendance. The world, and most of the church, would say there isn't any way she will ever get married, because all of the modern procedures for obtaining a mate are being neglected/ignored/rejected. That's what you call putting God in a very little box! She has set a wedding date of Dec 27 to marry a young man from Dallas (which is 160 miles from here).

The moral of the story is, God can accomplish what He wants, whether it conforms to the world's standards or not. In fact, you might say His response to our standards/thinking is, "Man's thinking be stinking!"

Not only is there a moral to the story, but there is encouragement to be content no matter what state we are in and to wait upon the Lord and His timing.



And the fact that you're committing the sin of judgement against women who were called by God to ministry, doesn't factor into your thinking in the least. Sorry, Bub, but you're not God so stop acting as if you are.


Tigress Tigress

"Name a shrub after me. Preferably one that's prickly and difficult to eradicate."

-Captain Jack Aubrey
"Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World"

Back to Top
 

honorman
Registered Member


Date Joined Oct 2002
Total Posts : 1137
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 5:34 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
I, personally, have not really investigated the issue that fully, but I would say all are called to ministry in some way. However, how that ministry comes about and how it is used are different issues. I understand what you are saying Tigress, but just because a woman is called to ministry doesn't mean that ministry is called to be teaching a man (or being over a man. Although that may be the case). I think to answer Paul you would have to deal with the scripture in question.
In conclusion and in comment on your personal story Paul, the fact that your daughter found a husband doesn't surprise me at all and it truly has nothing to do with miracles or God's will of anything. Pure women are hard to find in this day and age.
Back to Top
 

Springs
Registered Member


Date Joined Jul 2001
Total Posts : 636
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 10:01 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.

Tigress, in all due respect, I think you need to delete your post of 8/26/03 at 1:57:46.

T: "Your poor daughter has probably been miserable..."

S: How do know his daughter's emotional state?

T: "living in your prison for the last 30 years."

S: This is judgemental and insulting

T: "She's probably anxious..."

S: This is a mind read

T: "And of course she'd never..."

S: This is pure speculation or prophecy

T: "so her pain is invisible..."

S: Omniscience?

T: "she'll probably end up being..."

S: Are you a prophet?

T: "she had a cruel father..."
"She'll end up..."

S: Prophetic curse?

T: "It's happened before and it's happening again with your daughter."

S: Outragious.

Maybe after you delete it you could apologize to Paul. (Just a thought)

Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 10:05 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Tigress,

My daughter is quite happy, thank you.

BTW, this wasn't the first time she could have married.
Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 10:14 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Honorman,

I appreciate your comments and I will heartily agree that it is very hard to find pure women today.

*********************
Springs,

Hopefully your comments originate from recognizing that I do have a heart and I do care for the welfare of my children. Thank you for your input. Smile
Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 10:24 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Tigress,

It would be helpful if you had any idea of what you are talking about. One does not have to experience sin in order to know it is sin. If I tell my daughter to leave snakes alone, she really doesn't have to grab one in the nesting boxes, or recently in a sewing basket, to know I am right. If I tell her the way to a man's heart is through his stomach, not the length of the slit in her skirt, she then understands we are going to eat until we die, but given time we will get as homely as homemade soap. Looks fade, appetites don't! BTW, she can cook!
Back to Top
 

Tigress
Registered Member


Date Joined Feb 2003
Total Posts : 1252
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 10:27 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
quote:
Originally posted by Paul5388

Tigress,

It would be helpful if you had any idea of what you are talking about. One does not have to experience sin in order to know it is sin. If I tell my daughter to leave snakes alone, she really doesn't have to grab one in the nesting boxes, or recently in a sewing basket, to know I am right. If I tell her the way to a man's heart is through his stomach, not the length of the slit in her skirt, she then understands we are going to eat until we die, but given time we will get as homely as homemade soap. Looks fade, appetites don't! BTW, she can cook!



What in the world are you talking about?! I'm saying that a 30-year-old woman doesn't and shouldn't need her dad to warn her away from sin in order to live safely in this world! I don't think she needs to experience sin, either. She needs to experience life away from her parents so as to fully depend on God alone so she can grow spiritually.


Tigress Tigress

"Name a shrub after me. Preferably one that's prickly and difficult to eradicate."

-Captain Jack Aubrey
"Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World"

Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 10:37 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Tigress,

Let's check track records. How many children have you raised to maturity? My oldest is my son, who lives across the highway from me. He and his family moved back from Tulsa to be right across the highway. He could have moved any place on this earth, but didn't. My oldest daughter got married and moved to Dallas with her husband. They now live ten miles from here as I write. They could have moved any place on this earth, but didn't. I have eight grandchildren that visit on a daily basis. I must be a really raunchy old cuss for them to want to come and visit. Now, tell me how many you have raised and how well they turned out.
Back to Top
 

Tigress
Registered Member


Date Joined Feb 2003
Total Posts : 1252
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 10:46 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
quote:
Originally posted by Paul5388

Tigress,

Let's check track records. How many children have you raised to maturity? My oldest is my son, who lives across the highway from me. He and his family moved back from Tulsa to be right across the highway. He could have moved any place on this earth, but didn't. My oldest daughter got married and moved to Dallas with her husband. They now live ten miles from here as I write. They could have moved any place on this earth, but didn't. I have eight grandchildren that visit on a daily basis. I must be a really raunchy old cuss for them to want to come and visit. Now, tell me how many you have raised and how well they turned out.



You don't have to raise a child to recognize an unhealty living situation. A 30-year-old woman shouldn't need to live with her parents or anyone. She should be able to take care of herself with God's help. To go straight from her parents' house to marriage is dangerous as it doesn't give her the time to be herself without anyone to influence her or her thinking.


Tigress Tigress

"Name a shrub after me. Preferably one that's prickly and difficult to eradicate."

-Captain Jack Aubrey
"Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World"

Back to Top
 

John Earp
Registered Member


Date Joined Oct 2002
Total Posts : 1715
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 11:10 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
First, the command for women to "keep silent in the churches," (along with the command that they "not teach, nor usurp authority over a man,"*) must, as all scripture, be interpreted in context, both textually and culturally. What this passage appears to address is the problem of the apparently out-of-hand situation at Corinth, where ladies were apparently interrupting the services continually, asking doctrinal questions during teaching and preaching.

This can not be a command to utter silence, as Paul's instructions in 11:5 of 1 Cor. clearly refers to women "prophesying or praying" (note he does not forbid this, only gives instruction as to the proper way to have this happen) in a meeting should observe proper decorum in order to permit a worship service to be as profitable to all as possible. The injunction to keep silent, if interpreted in the context, is meant to curb unruly behavior, not women's participation in general, as I understand scripture to teach. Paul makes it quite clear that "in Christ" there is neither "slave nor free, Jew nor Gentile, Greek nor Barbarian, male nor female, but we are all one in Christ Jesus."

In fact, in the last chapter of Romans (16) Paul refers to several women who were active in the recognized ministry of the early Church, including Phoebe (who is referred to by the same word which is used for "minister" or "servant" all throughout the NT--by Christ, Paul, and others), who apparently had a very visible role in the carrying of this most important letter to Rome. Not only this, Junia is mentioned in v.7 as a female apostle, something unnoticed or unrecognized by many people today. I believe there are six or seven ladies mentioned here, all with a commendation of their ministry by Paul in ch. 16 of Romans alone.

*With regard to Paul's statement, "I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over a man,” Dr. Spiros Zodhiates, a native of Cyprus (who is also a native Modern Greek speaker) and respected fundamentalist theologian, in his _Complete Word Study New Testament_ (AMG Bible Publishers) footnote on this verse points out that the words for woman and man here are the same as for wife and husband (which the following phrase, "saved in childbearing" would bear out, too), and that the word teach here is better translated "to dictate to" or "speak authoritatively to" (or to boss around, in other words), and that this does not in context mean that no women can ever teach men in the church, necessarily.

Related to this my question is, "If women are not qualified to teach men because of their gullibility or some other character flaw somehow inherited through Eve, how can we say that they are qualified to teach other women, young ladies, children, or even anybody at all?" Wouldn't the same disqualifications apply to them teaching each other, as they would surely lead each other into deeper and deeper deception thus, if indeed they are somehow not able to teach men, as some interpret this passage to mean?

As to their being "saved by childbearing," it is well recognized by Greek scholars that the word here translated "by" can just as easily be translated "through" or "in," making this verse make much more sense, IMO. That is, in the time the NT was written death during childbirth was not uncommon, and apparently this not a restriction on women but rather a promise of health and safe delivery of babies through prayer.

From an historical point of view, there is evidence nearly from the start of the post apostolic period (A.D. 100 to 325) of women being recognized in official status as orders of Eldresses, Deaconesses, and Virgins. (Irenaeus, Bishop of Lyons referred to all three of these categories and paralleled them to the male offices of Elder, Deacon, and Virgin). Tertullian (ca. 175-220 A.D.), Bishop of Carthage spoke of all these offices as well, in addition to prophetesses. Interestingly all these offices were referred to in the original NT writings in Greek, but were translated later as "elder's wife," "deacon's wife," etc., apparently by someone who had an axe to grind. There are also extant today in some of the catacombs Christian paintings of ladies dressed in priestly garments in the position of a bishop giving a blessing.

Finally, with the marriage of the Church to the Roman Empire in the fourth century A.D., women were first banned from being bishops, later from being priests, then deacons, and so on, until all they were allowed to do was pray silently and sing with the congregation as part of the worship. These official rulings by the Church councils presupposes that some women were indeed exercising such roles at the time, else such rulings make no sense at all--if women had not been active in such ministry at the time, and had in fact been forbidden from public ministry since apostolic times, no such ruling in the fourth and fifth would have been necessary.

For more information on this subject I would refer you to the _Concise Evangelical Dictionary of Theology_, (Baker Book House, 1984), article entitled "Women, Role of in the Church," as well as the Assemblies of God and Foursquare position papers concerning women in ministry.

Sincerely and respectfully submitted for your kind consideration.

God bless,

John
(A guy who thinks women usually are much more spiritual than men, and that they are the most wonderful of all God's creation, not to mention a vast improvement on us ugly old guys).

P.S.: Tigress, I second Springs' admonition to you. Your judgmental comments towards Paul are entirely uncharitable and uncalled for. You seem to be reading into his relationship with his daughter what YOU think it would be like.



"The Discovery of new truth will modify old views and opinions, and there is perhaps no end to this process with finite minds in any world." Charles G. Finney, Systematic Theology.

revivaltheology.net

Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 11:17 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
As promised on the Wifely Submission thread, here is my daughter's response to Tigress,
quote:
Tigress,
Just thought I would pop in.....I over read some interesting comments that you made about that “Paul guy over on the Women in the Ministry thread”. I happen to be that daughter that you commented about that is “being suffocated”. Hmmm...interesting thought for certain !!! I am HAPPILY living by MY choice with my wonderful family and have been for TWENTY-NINE years. A more loving and caring family you will never find. I have been given the “right” to make any choice I want to, but counsel has been given when asked. I am only 29, my Father and Mother are 30 years older than I and therefore have MUCH wisdom....through studying Scripture and living life. I would have made some REALLY stupid decisions in my life had it not been for them guiding me and directing me in the right way. My parents love me very much and WANT the BEST for me. Hence the reason for me ASKING their counsel.

I am NOT suffocated in the LEAST !!! I have been given their blessing to marry a VERY special young man that loves me with all his heart and HE also has lived the same blessed life I have had by staying under his parent’s authority and counsel all HIS life. My parents and I know that I have been given every chance in this world to be the best I can be and I feel they have done a terrific job !!!

That “Paul guy” is a great Dad and I am proud to call him mine !!! I wish their were more Dad’s like him out in the world !!!!


EDIT: "over read" is similar to "over heard", but in a non-vocal sense.
Back to Top
 

Tigress
Registered Member


Date Joined Feb 2003
Total Posts : 1252
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 11:57 AM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Paul,
I'm sorry. I don't know what's gotten into me lately. I guess I've just seen all the pain and hurt that's been caused by husbands and fathers who have taken the usually fundamentalist position of keeping their women at home until marriage. I didn't know if you were doing that to your daughters or not. I doubted that your word alone could be trustworthy as of course many fundamentalist men tend to think they can speak for their women, because they have the "authority." I just think that the most loving thing you could do for all your children is to not let them keep living with you after they've been out of college a few years, which is usually the age of 24 or so, in order for them to understand how to live on their own and completely depend on God, alone.

My brother is almost 35 and is mooching off my parents who are not being stern enough to kick him out. He's afraid to live independently, and they're simply enabling him to cave in to his fears. It's not loving to do that. So, any time I see parents doing this, I get suspicious of a problem of co-dependancy. I'm glad that you at least listened to what I had to say, as rude as I was. I had no right to insult you or your parenting, but I guess I've been feeling pretty distrustful of men lately, for some reason. I see so much harm being done in the name of male authority in families that it sickens me.

It seems as though you're not that way, and it's a relief.

Again, I'm sorry for my irrational outbursts and accusations.


Tigress Tigress

"Name a shrub after me. Preferably one that's prickly and difficult to eradicate."

-Captain Jack Aubrey
"Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World"

Back to Top
 

honorman
Registered Member


Date Joined Oct 2002
Total Posts : 1137
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 12:15 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Having all my children live right near me?! What would I want that for? I already raised them! Personally, I would find that alarming, almost cultish. But that's just me. I want my children to live their own lives, see the world as I have.
This is not directed at you Paul, but if I read such a story in the newspaper I would think the same thing. I want my children living within the vicinity near me. But the thought that they would want to live on the same street and that my daughter would want to live with me until she was 30 and married strikes me as, at the least, odd, and at the most unhealthy. Women do not have to get married to leave their parents home, nor do they have to rely on a man, whether it be me or a husband, to be fulfulled. Women are unique INDIVIDUAL creatures in God, defined by God, not by the man they marry. They can think for themselves, act on their own and live their own lives.
BTW Interesting comments from your daughter. However, I am suspect of anyone who completely, without hesitation, has nothing but undiluted praise for anyone. Sounds much too scripted. Like someone died or something. One of the wonderful things I've found out about parenting is allowing your children to feel comfortable enough and secure enough in the love you have for them to be critical of you.
Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 12:55 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
Tigress,

I replied to your latest post on the Wifely Submission thread, which is much longer than this post.

I repeat, I don't harbor any ill feelings toward you and I repeat again that I pray you will find peace and happiness in the Lord.
*******************

John,

I have been a little distracted today. I will answer your post later tonight.
Back to Top
 

PotOnWheel
Registered Member




Date Joined Jul 2001
Total Posts : 9890
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 4:55 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
www.stnina.org/0/0-00.htm

quote:
Main Articles
Nancy Holloway,
The Lenten Journey (1997 Spring)

Kyriaki Karidoyannes FitzGerald,
Silence and the Glad Tidings (1997 Spring)

Demetra Jaquet,
Pentecost Sunday (1997 Spring)

Valerie Karras,
The Holy Myrrh-Bearers in the Church of Jerusalem (1997 Spring)
The Significance of the Maleness of Jesus Christ (1997 Spring)

Karen Rae Keck,
The Life of Mary Magdalene (1997 Spring)
The Holy Myrrh-Bearers (1997 Spring)

Bonnie A. Michal,
From Repentance to Love: The Sinful Woman (1997 Spring)

Teva Regule,
Washing of the Feet (1997 Spring)
Reflections on Holy Week... (1997 Spring)
"Gifts of the Spirit" Conference 2000

Eva Catafygiotu Topping,
After Easter Reflections 1986 (1997 Spring)

Bishop Kallistos (Ware),
The Theotokos, Icon of Human Freedom (1997 Summer)

St. Nina Quarterly staff,
An Interview with Bishop Kallistos (Ware) (1997 Summer)

Karen Rae Keck,
The Life of St. Macrina the Younger (1997 Summer)

Helen Creticos Theodoropoulos,
The Joy of All Who Sorrow (1997 Summer)

Susan Ashbrook Harvey,
Women in the Syrian Tradition (1997 Fall)

St. Nina Quarterly staff,
An Interview with Susan Ashbrook Harvey (1997 Fall)

A Spiritual Son,
The Life of Gerontissa Gabriela, (1997 Fall)

Kyriaki Karidoyanes FitzGerald,
On Holiness, Authority, and St. Brigit of Kildare (1997 Fall)


Back to Top
 

PotOnWheel
Registered Member




Date Joined Jul 2001
Total Posts : 9890
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 4:58 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
quote:
Conferences, Retreats, & Seminars
Teva Regule
Gifts of the Spirit Conference for Orthodox
Christian Women, November 17-18, 2000,
St. John of Damascus Orthodox Church,
Dedham, Massachusetts

St. Nina Quarterly staff,
Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew Hosts
International Conference for Orthodox Women (1997 Fall)

Cathleen Callen & Lisa Pook
A Journey in Faith: A Conference for Orthodox Christian Women (1997 Summer)

Evelyn Dumas
Living by Acts of Faith: Women’s Conference in Montreal (1997 Summer)


Back to Top
 

PotOnWheel
Registered Member




Date Joined Jul 2001
Total Posts : 9890
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 5:01 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.

www.stnina.org/97f/97f-ecupat-conf.htm

quote:
Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew Hosts International Conference for Orthodox Women



His All Holiness Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew was the host of a conference for Orthodox women entitled "Discerning the ‘Signs of the Times’ (Mt. 16:3): Women in the Life of the Orthodox Church" held in Constantinople, May 10—17, 1997.

Sponsored by World Council of Churches, the conference brought together about fifty women who were the official delegates of the Orthodox Churches and the Oriental Orthodox Churches, representing the concerns of Orthodox women from Eastern and Western Europe, Russia, North and South America.

The focus of the conference included a number of topics related to women in the Orthodox Church. Among those discussed were: "The Holy Spirit in the Life of the Church," "Discerning the Tradition Today," "Growing Up Orthodox and Female," "Women and Contemporary Pastoral Praxis," "Orthodox Women in Monastic Life," "Orthodox Theological Education and Women," "The Ministry of Wives of Priests," "Women as Young Adults," "Women and Aging," "Women and the Body," "The Diaconal Ministries and the Diaconate," and "The Ordination Issue."

Serving as the theological coordinator of the conference, Dr. Kyriaki Karidoyanes FitzGerald reminded the delegates that they were present with the blessing of their Church leaders. "Our conference," she said, "is taking place with the full encouragement and blessings of our Patriarchs, Archbishops, and Metropolitans. We are representatives of our churches. Our primates have already affirmed that our meeting is an important one for our churches and for Orthodox Christian witness in the societies in which we live."

Conference participants recommended that the churches take more positive actions in affirming and supporting the vocations of women. The delegates, for example, stressed the need for more women to have the opportunity to study Orthodox theology.

As there were a number of participants from war-torn areas of Eastern Europe, delegates spoke of women as "peacemakers" and called upon the churches to make "a greater commitment to support our sister Orthodox churches in crisis situations. Often in these situations, women and children suffer most."

A number of other concerns which relate to the ministry of women were also discussed. Many of the delegates expressed concern regarding certain liturgical practices regarding the presentation of infants, certain prayers associated with miscarriage, abortion, postpartum mothers, and the assumptions which in some places prohibit women from receiving communion for biological reasons. These concerns were discussed by the participants openly, yet with great sensitivity. The delegates re- cognized the need to examine more thoughtfully the present relationship between theology and praxis (practice).

There were also discussions regarding the rejuvenation of the female diaconate. The delegates were encouraged to reflect deeply upon this tradition. In his welcoming address of Patriarch Bartholomew reminded the participants that "Here, at the Great Church of Hagia Sophia, a number of devoted women such as St. Olympias, served as deaconesses . . . To both women and men, to both clergy and laity, these women saints continue to be a source of inspiration, for it is written, ‘God is revealed in His saints!’" His Holiness also noted the "call for the full restoration of the order of women deacons . . . The order of women deacons is an undeniable part of tradition coming from the early Church. Now, in many of our Churches, there is a growing desire to restore this order so that the spiritual needs of the people of God may be better served. There are already a number of women who appear to be called to this ministry."

"Perhaps one of the most remarkable results of these two international Orthodox conferences, [the other conference was "Discerning the Signs of the Times" held in Damascus, Syria, October, 1996]" stated FitzGerald, "is that, now, at least at a symbolic level, we have for the first time a global consensus regarding a number of the important concerns that affect Orthodox women. This indeed, may prove to be of immediate and future service to the Church."
Back to Top
 

PotOnWheel
Registered Member




Date Joined Jul 2001
Total Posts : 9890
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 5:03 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
www.stnina.org/99/Confwrap.htm

quote:



Gifts of the Spirit
A Conference for Orthodox Christian Women
Teva Regule, Managing Editor for The St. Nina Quarterly
Home

Nearly two hundred and fifty women gathered this past 17 an 18 November at St. John of Damascus Orthodox Church in Dedham, Mass. to participate in a conference for Orthodox Christian women entitled, "Gifts of the Spirit." Sponsored by the St. Nina Quarterly and the Council of Eastern Orthodox Churches of Central Massachusetts, and with the help of a dedicated local planning committee, this was the first time that Orthodox Christian women in the New England area gathered as one to explore the ministry of women in the Church. The event offered an opportunity to meet other Orthodox Christian women, exchange our experiences and ideas of ministry within the Church, grow in our understanding of ministry, and further explore the various ministries of women in the Church.

It was a tremendous success. Although originally envisioned as a regional event, the conference attracted women from all over the United States. They came from many different ethnic jurisdictions and parishes, and ranged in age from teenagers to women in their eighties (we had quite a few mother-daughter pairs). Some had graduate degrees in theology. Some were faithful women in their parishes who had never studied theology formally. We were a diverse group, but we gathered as one in Christ. We formed new friendships and renewed old ones. We shared experiences and feelings. We discussed and debated theology. We lived, shared, and exalted in the gifts and ministries of women in the Church. It was an exhilarating experience for many of the participants.

The conference began on Friday evening with registration, music rehearsal, and a light supper followed by Daily Vespers. Each participant received a workbook, with a cover icon of the Myrrhbearing Women by iconographer Diane Lee, containing descriptions of the numerous breakout sessions scheduled for Saturday, questions for consideration, and resource information. We also included copies of recommendations from a number of past international Orthodox conferences for women (1976–Agapia, Romania; 1988–Rhodes, Greece; 1996–Damascus, Syria; 1997–Istanbul, Turkey; and 1998–Nairobi, Kenya); a ministry worksheet; and the conference evaluation. In addition, each conferencee received a bookmark with the quotations from the scroll given to St. Nina, a conference pencil, and a print of one of nine different icons by a number of women iconographers. (These icons were later used to designate the respective discussion group to which each conferencee was assigned during the closing plenary.)

After Vespers, Susan Arida, a member of the conference planning committee, introduced the ministry worksheet that was included in each participant’s packet. She explained that the worksheet was offered as a starting point for our discussions for the weekend and as a resource for helping us work through the many ideas that were presented at the conference. The questions on the worksheet focused on the purpose of ministry and our understanding of the various gifts of the Spirit.

Susan Ashbrook Harvey, professor of religious studies at Brown University, immediate past president of the North American Patristics Society, and a representative of the Antiochian Archdiocese on the North American Eastern Orthodox-Roman Catholic Bilateral Theological Consultation was the opening keynote speaker. In her talk, "Gifts We Have Been Given: Women in Orthodox History," Dr. Ashbrook Harvey presented the stories of various women from the past (in situations not unlike our own today), who, in spite of societal circumstances, distinguished themselves as disciples of Christ. She drew on biblical and patristic sources, as well as ancient writings to show the many ways in which women have offered their gifts to God in the past.

After a lively question and answer session, everyone enjoyed the hospitality at the opening reception. With live piano music in the background, conferencees browsed through the conference bookstore as well as the many displays and videos featuring the various ministries of women in the Church including: Holy Trinity and Hellenic Nursing Home and Rehabilitation centers; St. Herman Food Pantry; International Orthodox Christian Charities; Project Mexico; Orthodox People Together; Orthodox Peace Fellowship; Theophany School; the St. Macrina study group; Circle of Healing care ministry; Philoptochos Society; Antiochian Women; Women’s Orthodox Ministries and Education Network; and the St. Nina Quarterly.

Saturday began with the celebration of the Divine Liturgy. The service was conducted as a teaching liturgy with the altar table and table of preparation in front of the iconostasis. The main celebrant, Fr. Nicholas Apostola, explained the various parts of the liturgy and those in attendance were able to watch and gain a deeper understanding of the service. The participants were also given a service booklet prepared especially for the conference including the prayers, petitions, and musical responses so that everyone could actively join in worship. We were further inspired by the homily given by Susan Arida, M. Div., who reflected on the readings of the day and, in particular, what it means to follow Christ. It was uplifting to hear everyone offering their gifts to God–singing, praying, and exchanging the Kiss of Peace together. We are truly one in Christ.

Following a continental breakfast, participants attended the morning breakout session of their choice. The topics included: Educating our Children and Ourselves in the Faith: In Our Homes; Pastoral Ministry–A Lay Ministries Panel that included women representatives of the various pastoral care ministries in the area; Language and Imagery in Worship: Iconography and Sacred Space; Saints and Sisterhood: Women in the Church Past and Present; and Women and the Church Canons. Each session provided a chance for participants to explore a particular area of interest and to engage in a question and answer session. For those who wanted either to continue or participate in the various discussions, a number of tables at lunch were designated as theme tables.

The luncheon featured a delicious lenten middle eastern buffet. The International Orthodox Christian Charities generously donated prayer cards that were placed at each place setting featuring the before and after meal prayers so everyone could lift up their voices together. It was also at this time that the editorial board of the St. Nina Quarterly paid special tribute to Ms. Clara Nickolson, a member of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of North America, by presenting the first St. Nina Award–an engraved wooden cross (According to the Life of St. Nina, she was presented with a vine-covered wooden cross from the Theotokos as a sign of special protection during her ministry.) –in recognition of all her years of work in support of the ministry of women in the Orthodox Church.

Dr. Kyriaki Karidoyanes FitzGerald gave the second keynote address, "Offering Our Gifts: Our Faith and Praxis." Dr. FitzGerald is an Orthodox theologian, educator, pastoral counselor, and licensed psychologist, as well as author of several books including Women Deacons in the Orthodox Church: Called to Holiness and Ministry. She began her talk by outlining some of the mistaken notions about Church service, explaining our life of discipleship that begins with our baptism and chrismation, the necessity of placing God first, love of our neighbor, and our place in the Christian community. She then focused on the ministries of women, pointing out the many ways that women had served the Lord in the past as apostles, prophets, deacons, nuns, ascetics, etc. and highlighting some of the ways that women may be called to serve in the present.

In addition, she presented a number of concerns from the past international conferences for Orthodox women to illustrate the global consensus regarding a number of vital issues that are important to all Orthodox women. As the Orthodox theological coordinator for both the Istanbul and Damascus conferences, Dr. FitzGerald related some of the concerns of the delegates at these conferences: "even regarding ministries which we know are appropriate to the laity, there appears to be an issue of inequity regarding the ministry of laywomen." As examples, she cited the dissimilar ways in which infants are churched, the welcoming of only male acolytes (altar servers) and tonsured chanters. She concluded by emphasizing that when we speak of women’s public service to the Church, we must be "careful to differentiate between the cultural norms of the time and our life-giving theology." During the question and answer session, many conferencees shared some of their own experiences in the Church.

Many of these topics were further developed during the afternoon breakout sessions. Topics included: Educating Our Children and Ourselves in the Faith: In our Parishes; the Female Diaconate; Language and Imagery in Worship: Translations and Hymnography; Saints of Our Day–An Oral History Project; and Women and the Writings of the Fathers/Mothers of the Church. Once again, participants attended the session of their choice.

In the late afternoon the conferencees gathered once again for the closing plenary. First, everyone was divided into small discussion groups (determined by the icon print they had received during registration) during which they had the opportunity to refer back to the ministry worksheet that had been introduced at the beginning of the conference and to reflect on their understanding of the questions. In addition, everyone had the opportunity to evaluate the conference and to begin to address the question, "where do we go from here?" One universal answer was to have more conferences for Orthodox women. (We have already received several inquiries about replicating this past conference in other major metropolitan areas in the United States including Chicago, Washington, D.C., Berkeley and the Seattle/Portland area.)

Valerie Zahirsky, M. Div., who led the education breakout sessions, gave a closing mediation on the conference. She highlighted the events of the conference and set the mood for returning to our home parishes. As a final serenade, Bonnie Michal, musical coordinator for the conference, assembled a quartet to bid the conferencees a peaceful farewell by singing the French Orthodox setting of, "I leave you my peace."

With the glow of the conference still with us, we turn our attention back to publishing the issues of The St. Nina Quarterly with a renewed spirit and common purpose. Our experience and our understanding of our Church continues to grow. Our celebration of the Divine Liturgy at the conference was, as one participant said,

the most beautiful, peaceful, prayerful, uplifting Liturgy that I had ever attended. It was wonderful to pray where so many women were using their gifts for the glory of God–iconographers, chanters, readers, homilists. . . .

Truly, as we proclaim in the motto of the Quarterly, "To each one is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the Common good." [1 Corinthians 12:7]

_____

For more information regarding the Gifts of the Spirit Conference, including tapes of the main talks or the St. Nina Quarterly, please contact The St. Nina Quarterly, PO Box 397252, Cambridge, MA 02139. EmailW.O.M.E.N.

The St. Nina Quarterly plans to publish an issue devoted to the conference including the main talks, a synopsis of the various breakout sessions, the ministry worksheet, the sermon, reflections and pictures.




Back to Top
 

Paul5388
Registered Member


Date Joined Apr 2003
Total Posts : 295
 
   Posted 8/26/2003 7:22 PM (GMT -6)    Quote This PostAlert An Admin About This Post.
John,

Let me preface by saying that part of the disagrement we have on this issue is probably due to different church backgrounds. Even if we don't admit it, those backgrounds color our understanding of scripture.

There is an assumption that there is a need to let the "culture" be a basis for what scripture says. I admit there was a culture in place when the scriptures were written, but cultures changed during the span of revelation when the Word of God was being written. The Word is/was applicable regardless of culture. If one would think about the various cultures represented by just the recepients of the letters of Paul, one would see there was great diversity and yet there was only one rule for all. In I Cor 11.16, Paul says, we have no such custom, neither the churches of God, meaning there is only one practice in all of the churches, regardless of culture and Corinth needs to conform to the other churches. Surely you don't think the culture in Corinth was the same as the culture in Smyrna? I have been to Greece (I guess the island of Rhodes is part of Greece?) and Izmir, Turkey (modern Smyrna) and believe me, they are far different in culture. The Byzantine culture was far different from Greek culture in the 1st century also.

I don't know about it appearing to be anything in I Cor 14, I just know what it says and I have already answered how one can prophesy and not speak. OTOH, I could say it appears that there were some rude women in Corinth, who talked during the service and Paul was being nice by suggesting they were asking their husbands questions and they should wait until they got home to ask those questions. As an aside, I can make the observation that it was more proper to ask questions of their husband, the one who is supposed to lead them, than it was to ask the person speaking.

As far as there being no difference between men and women, my wife is the one with long hair and a head covering, I am the one with short hair and a beard. Obviously, there is a difference, not of worth, but of form and function.

Women can teach other women many things you or I can't teach them. I can teach a woman what the Bible says, but I can't teach them how to be a christian woman. Mainly because I don't think like a woman. Men take a direct and sometimes forceful route and women know how to be more subtle and less forceful. Where I would probably say to my son, "Boy, I think you stepped in some cow manure", my wife would probably say, "Son, why don't you go outside and wipe your feet". There's a difference in the way they communicate!

I find it unusual that Ryrie would fail to consider history and the early fathers. However, this is what Tertullian, who died around 230 AD, says,
quote:
It is not permitted to a woman to speak in the church; but neither is it permitted her to teach, nor to baptize, nor to offer, nor to claim to herself a lot in any manly function, nor to say sacerdotal office. De Virginibus Velandis, 4.


Concerning Junia, I don't read that she was an apostle at all. Among the apostles she was noted, not that she was part of the apostles.

The banning during the 4th century may have been due to a few groups, but the Tertullian quote certainly casts some doubt on even that.

Last, I am not trying to be derogatory at all when I say this, but groups who have much of their origin based on the ministry of women will have a different view/bias toward their public ministry. The holiness groups that rose up around the latter part of the 19th century have a large number of women in public ministry. My mother's family was mostly Nazarene, which had its birth in the holiness movement, and they have many women pastors just as the Assembly of God does. I believe the Four Square may also be in that group.

With all of this being said, and considering our different views, I don't have any problem recognizing you as a brother in Christ.

Contend for the faith, and hopefully I can discuss the rest in a civil manner!
Back to Top
 
New Topic Post Reply Printable Version
54 posts in this thread.
Viewing Page :
 1  2  3 
   
Forum Information
Currently it is Monday, November 09, 2026 2:29 PM (GMT -6)
There are a total of 97,718 posts in 6,040 threads.
In the last 3 days there were 0 new threads and 0 reply posts. View Active Threads