 |
Open Theism Discussion Board > Public Forums > Tearing down walls > (No Subject) | Forum Quick Jump
|
|  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/21/2003 7:56 AM (GMT -6) |   | What does true forgiveness feel like?
I'm struggling with knowing what it really means to forgive and what I am supposed to feel like afterwards. This is something that I always felt came very natural or easy for me my whole life. I didn't hold grudges. I loved to seek closure with anyone I thought I had hurt or had hurt me. I found it easy to move on and put those things in the past. That was until 3 years ago when my whole idea of forgiveness was turned upside down. I was hurt by someone and the ramifications of that hurt were deep, with many after effects that still continue to this day. I wanted so badly to do what had always come easy for me and in my heart I wanted more than anything to forgive and move on. It has been such a painful process and I don't know what I am supposed to feel now. For many reasons this wound is being reopened with this person after 3 years.
What should I feel towards this person? The very mention of his name causes me to react physically. My face flushes, my heart pounds, I get anxious, I feel sick to my stomach. I feel anger when I hear that he continues to deceive and to lie to people I really care about. I wish for justice for all of the people he has left in his wake. He has harmed people financially, emotionally...without any recognition or repentence, and he is a Christian. On the other hand I feel sorry for him, the mess he has made of his life, the crappy childhood he had. I feel sorry for his wife, his children...the fact that he has now lost everything...
I don't hate him... but I don't like him...I still feel anger towards what he has done, and continues to do....
What is forgiveness? What does it feel like? What should I feel towards this person if I have truly forgiven him? How does one let go? I'm very perplexed by my feelings because in my heart of hearts I WANT to be a forgiving person. In many ways I feel that I have forgiven him and have made that "decision" many times...but then what exactly does that mean?
Help! Shell
Edited by - shell on 05/21/2003 2:36:25 PM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Laika Registered Member

Date Joined Mar 2003 Total Posts : 2433 | Posted 5/21/2003 8:33 AM (GMT -6) |   | shell
quote:
What does true forgiveness feel like?
I think absence helps. When Jesus told His disciples to forgive seventy times seven, to me anyway, it meant to do it whether you felt like it or not. If you've truly forgiven someone, if a feeling comes up like you didn't, that might our adversary trying to get you to doubt. My wife had some abuse from someone else before I met her, once we were married this person demanded that we all be friends but my wife and I decided that, even though she forgave the guy, absence was the best policy henceforth.
Does that make sense? "I forgive you but never want to see you again." That kind of thing.

Even though the skies are blue, don't they let the sunshine through?
Edited by - Laika on 05/21/2003 1:34:56 PM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  S.B.G. Registered Member
 Date Joined Jan 2003 Total Posts : 143 | Posted 5/21/2003 10:34 AM (GMT -6) |   | Shell, I think forgiveness can be a process and depending on how deeply we've been wounded, we may have to "re-forgive" seventy times seven until the bitterness goes away. (we have probably in fact forgiven but it doesn't FEEL like we have) Some hurts are forgiven relatively easily, and we don't even think about it anymore, but others require loving effort, particularly if the person is in our lives re-opening the wound. Laika had sound advice, if you do not need to be around this person, don't.
In my life I have let an old Twila Paris song aide me in the forgiveness process, I will literally sing "I commit my love to you" with the person in my mind, and let Jesus take away the hurt and replace it with compassion..the very compassion you speak of experiencing. I worked with someone who hurt me deeply, and I "sang this song to her" many times on my way to work.
The salient verse says: And if you have offended me you know you are forgiven and I will not remember, I commit my love to you I will see the best in all you do and I will defend you when they come against you I commit my love to you
Chorus: For when we are divided, I can hear Him crying And I can't be a part of breaking His heart anymore So brother I commit my love to you
I am praying that Jesus will give you your own help to "re-forgive" if necessary.
S.B.G.
To understand and to be understood is bliss. | | Back to Top | | |
 |  DLW Registered Member
 Date Joined Apr 2003 Total Posts : 2457 | Posted 5/21/2003 11:37 AM (GMT -6) |   | forgiveness is hard, when the hurt is deep and the other person doesn't acknowledge that they did wrong.
But we have to turn things over to the cross.
Otherwise, the anger will fester into hate and spread to the rest of our lives.
dlw
Prayer from Kenya
From the Cowardice that dare not face new truth, From the Laziness that is contented with half-truth, From the Arrogance that thinks it knows all truth, Lord Deliver Me. | | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/22/2003 5:59 PM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
Shell, I think forgiveness can be a process and depending on how deeply we've been wounded, we may have to "re-forgive" seventy times seven until the bitterness goes away. (we have probably in fact forgiven but it doesn't FEEL like we have) Some hurts are forgiven relatively easily, and we don't even think about it anymore, but others require loving effort, particularly if the person is in our lives re-opening the wound. Laika had sound advice, if you do not need to be around this person, don't.
SHELL: Thank you Laika, S.B.G. and DLW for your responses. I qouted the above by S.B.G. and this was very similar to Laika's response as well. It helped me to think of it in terms of 70 x 7 and "re-forgiving" every time those old feelings pop up. I hadn't thought of it in that way before, just handing it back over to God each time those feelings come back. I've just kept feeling those feelings should be gone and never come back...but maybe that is unrealistic at this point...
I have been able to pretty much block this person out of my life for the past 2 1/2 yrs or so. It's just that recently some unavoidable contact has created all of these feelings to creep in again. I'm totally with you both that the absence thing is the best. When I have no contact with this person I don't dwell on the past at all or feel hatred or bitterness towards him. Although, I have always felt that I should be able to handle being around him or even just hearing about him. And now that that is happening and it isn't going well, I've been questioning the depth of my forgiveness.
Thank you for your thoughts on this. Shell
Edited by - shell on 05/22/2003 11:01:41 PM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  John Earp Registered Member
 Date Joined Oct 2002 Total Posts : 1715 | Posted 5/22/2003 7:22 PM (GMT -6) |   | To forgive is a choice. To feel warm feelings towards a person who has hurt us can never be instantaneous, may take years, and may in fact never happen. I think it is a big mistake to define forgiveness in terms of feelings.
"The Discovery of new truth will modify old views and opinions, and there is perhaps no end to this process with finite minds in any world." Charles G. Finney, Systematic Theology.
revivaltheology.net
| | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/22/2003 7:27 PM (GMT -6) |   | John, I think you're right.
This probably seems like a stupid question but what does it mean to make that choice? If feelings about that person don't change how do we know we've forgiven them and what does it look like then? What does it mean to truly forgive someone? What exactly are we choosing when we forgive? If I still feel such strong feelings towards this person(as I have recently realized that I do) and their continuation in hurtful behavior and refusal to change or be remorseful, how is that not still holding them responsible for their debt?
What is "Choosing" to forgive someone and what does it really mean? Does this seem like a ridiculous question? It kind of does to me after being a Christian for 25 years...but I'm asking sincerely.
thanks, Shell
Edited by - shell on 05/23/2003 01:02:17 AM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  John Earp Registered Member
 Date Joined Oct 2002 Total Posts : 1715 | Posted 5/22/2003 8:35 PM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
John, I think you're right.
This probably seems like a stupid question but what does it mean to make that choice? If feelings about that person don't change how do we know we've forgiven them and what does it look like then? What does it mean to truly forgive someone? What exactly are we choosing when we forgive? If I still feel such strong feelings towards this person(as I have recently realized that I do) and their continuation in hurtful behavior and refusal to change or be remorseful, how is that not still holding them responsible for their debt?
What is "Choosing" to forgive someone and what does it really mean? Does this seem like a ridiculous question? It kind of does to me after being a Christian for 25 years...but I'm asking sincerely.
Definitely not a stupid or ridiculous question, shell. My short answer, as my eyelids are getting heavy and my mind is probably already partially asleep, is that repentance is absolutely necessary before true forgiveness can ever really occur. In other words, I don't find the commonly accepted "Christian" phrase, "You HAVE to forgive, whether they say they're sorry or not" is true at all. God does not forgive in that way, and Jesus plainly tells us the conditions of forgiveness are IF he repents, then forgive him, 70 x 7, not "forgive regardless of if he ever says he's sorry."
As to whether or not you will feel differently as a result of your decision to forgive, I don't think that really is necessary for true forgiveness to occur. If a bank forgives a debt, it doesn't really matter how they "feel" about it, does it? only that they chose to do it.
That said, of course as Christians we must have a willingness to forgive and an ultimate motivation of unselfish goodwill (love), just as God does. I don't think you will really be able to make the choice to forgive unless and until the conditions for forgiveness are met by the offending party, though.
But that by no means means we should nurse a grudge, not at all. A grudge, as I understand it, has more to do with the emotional response we have to a person. In effect we focus anger and resentment on someone we feel has hurt us. I submit that the attitude underlying these emotions is what is wrong, not the emotions per se, the attitude of desiring to get even or at least for them to "get what's coming to them."
I'm definitely not in the position to counsel you about your specific situation, but from what I hear you saying, you're wanting this person to (1) say he's sorry and stop hurting others (which would only be right) and for yourself (2) to be free of these negative feelings towards him for what he did and continues to do. As your experience has taught you, you simply can't make him do the right thing (no one but he can choose to do that), and so #1 is pretty much completely out of your hands. #2 is something that takes the grace of God to accomplish in your life, whether through pastoral counseling, prayer, inner healing, or whatever other mode God may use to heal your soul.
Hope this helps.
"The Discovery of new truth will modify old views and opinions, and there is perhaps no end to this process with finite minds in any world." Charles G. Finney, Systematic Theology.
revivaltheology.net
Edited by - John Earp on 05/23/2003 01:36:47 AM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Matthew Timothy Short Huh?

Date Joined Apr 2002 Total Posts : 635 | Posted 5/23/2003 1:49 AM (GMT -6) |   | Luk 23:34 Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. And they parted his raiment, and cast lots.
From out here in left field, my Father looks masculine. - Me | | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/23/2003 3:02 AM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
But that by no means means we should nurse a grudge, not at all. A grudge, as I understand it, has more to do with the emotional response we have to a person. In effect we focus anger and resentment on someone we feel has hurt us. I submit that the attitude underlying these emotions is what is wrong, not the emotions per se, the attitude of desiring to get even or at least for them to "get what's coming to them."
I appreciate your response John and I'm still digesting it...I was half asleep last night when I posted my question and I still feel half asleep this morning so I won't go too much into it right now...but I have a question here about what John said above. So if I wouldn't MIND if this guy had to serve some time in jail for his lying, cheating and destructive ways that now recently involve much bigger consequences (and this could be a reality),and if I feel that at some point it would be good for him to sit in a small cell and think about what he's done to his life and others...is that unforgiveness?
Shell
Edited by - shell on 05/23/2003 08:16:34 AM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/23/2003 3:14 AM (GMT -6) |   | Also, another question. Since I do still have such strong feelings towards this guy...and he continues in his pattern of lying, cheating and destruction, and I know this, do I have an ethical responsiblity to inform a friend that he is lying to them? I feel that I do. But...is this because of my emotions towards this guy...is it desiring payback...to be honest I don't know? I just can't stand the thought that he is lying to one of my best friends.
Is it gossip to share with this close friend that they are being lied to and misled because it damages the reputation of the one doing the lying?
Shell
Edited by - shell on 05/23/2003 08:18:36 AM
Edited by - shell on 05/23/2003 09:32:03 AM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Laika Registered Member

Date Joined Mar 2003 Total Posts : 2433 | Posted 5/23/2003 3:19 AM (GMT -6) |   | shell
quote:
Also, another question. Since I do still have such strong feelings towards this guy...and he continues in his pattern of lying, cheating and destruction, and I know this, do I have an ethical responsiblity to inform a friend that he is lying to them?
If someone else was lying to your friend and you knew it, would you inform your friend? When/if you tell your friend, disclose your feelings for this person so your friend has all the information and can make an informed decision.

Even though the skies are blue, don't they let the sunshine through? | | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/23/2003 3:22 AM (GMT -6) |   | oops i edited and accidently double posted, I deleted it now.
| | Back to Top | | |
 |  S.B.G. Registered Member
 Date Joined Jan 2003 Total Posts : 143 | Posted 5/23/2003 4:13 AM (GMT -6) |   | I agree with Laika.
If you are certain, and can explain why you believe this person is lying, you need to protect your friend by telling him/her that he/she is being lied to. People can change, so it wouldn't be fair or loving to base your perception soley on your experience with him, but if you see/hear it happening again, you can warn your friend based on the current lies.
I would add also, that while it would be appropriate to warn a close friend, it would seem to cross the line of gossip to make a practice of telling others.
Don't ever forget mercy, and that EVERYONE can change.
S.B.G.
To understand and to be understood is bliss. | | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/23/2003 4:52 AM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
I agree with Laika.
If you are certain, and can explain why you believe this person is lying, you need to protect your friend by telling him/her that he/she is being lied to. People can change, so it wouldn't be fair or loving to base your perception soley on your experience with him, but if you see/hear it happening again, you can warn your friend based on the current lies.
I would add also, that while it would be appropriate to warn a close friend, it would seem to cross the line of gossip to make a practice of telling others.
Don't ever forget mercy, and that EVERYONE can change.
S.B.G.
To understand and to be understood is bliss.
Thanks S.B.G. Just to clarify where I am coming from (I must sound awful in some aspects). He is verifiably lying to my friend. I have known he has been lying to her and others for 2+ years( but I have specific new information as we have been dragged into his current situation) and have not felt okay about sharing this with her or others. If I thought she would be directly hurt by him, I would tell her right away. It's kind of just an insideous lying that causes my friend to support him and make choices regarding him that might not be for the best, but not really imminently damaging to her, if that makes sense? More of an enabling situation than anything. This friend doesn't know the details of even what happened to me, because I wanted to be careful how I handled it. I'm not sure if I will open up to her. My husband's view is that the truth always triumphs, and God doesn't need our help in bringing that about. In many ways in what has happened with this man, the truth has come out without us saying one word. It's just that right now he seems to be in his "grand finale" of lying and participation in all of our lives. Supposedly he's moving far away soon. I've been internally struggling with this for 2 weeks and that is why I decided to bounce it off this board, while not giving details. I haven't made a decision and because I've kept it to myself for over two years I am more likely to do that than to talk about it.
S.B.G. and Laika, I appreciate the input from both of you a lot. I agree so much about your comment on mercy and that everyone can chnge. I need mercy daily...and don't ever want to be a person that isn't readily willing to offer mercy and love to others. That is who I really am. I am just struggling internally with this and trying to reason with all of these emotions and hurts from the past. I do recognize his hurtful past and upbringing, I realize that he had no moral base installed as a child. I realize that he must feel awful deep down inside for the mess that he has made of his life. Yet...Each day he makes the choice to live a life of lies, despite his life crashing in around him. What does it take for some people to get a wake up call? It scares me that he seems so far gone. I just wish he would come clean and repent, show remorse and feeling towards others...
Still "thinking out loud" as Doc says. Thanks Shell
Edited by - shell on 05/23/2003 10:06:37 AM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  S.B.G. Registered Member
 Date Joined Jan 2003 Total Posts : 143 | Posted 5/23/2003 5:07 AM (GMT -6) |   | Shell, If you are financially able, I urge you to get a copy of "People of the Lie" by M.Scott Peck ASAP. You may very well be dealing with an evil person and you and your friend should keep your distance.
S.B.G.
To understand and to be understood is bliss.
Edited by - S.B.G. on 05/23/2003 11:47:43 AM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/23/2003 5:29 AM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
Shell, If you are financially able, I urge you to get a copy of "People of the Lie" by M.Scott Peck ASAP. You may very well be dealing with an evil person and you and your freind should keep your distance.
S.B.G.
To understand and to be understood is bliss.
I wish someone would have given me that advice about 6 years ago! Evil? Not sure about that...but at least he's really messed up. It just shows though that God gives us discernment of people's character and I should have heeded those warnings in my spirit years ago when I had questions.
Thanks again, Shell
Edited by - shell on 05/23/2003 2:52:50 PM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Tigress Registered Member
 Date Joined Feb 2003 Total Posts : 1252 | Posted 5/23/2003 11:18 AM (GMT -6) |   | Hi! Here's my two cents.
I suppose the pain and hurt you still feel around this guy even though you've forgiven him might be the same thing as physical wounds. Some wounds are so deep that they never heal completely right, so that if you move the wrong way, or it's damp outside or you've just overexerted yourself, the wound will be sore. So, I'm sure emotional wounds can be like this also. Even if you've done your job of forgiving him, it still takes time for your soul to recover from what he did to you. That's a consequence of his actions - not yours. And if you're right about his upbringing, his behavior is partly the consequences of one or both of his parents actions toward him. That's why sin is so insidious. It cuts to the core and invades the deepest recesses of our being, and it can take a long time for the wounds it makes to heal.
Tigress
The Angel of the Lord encamps around those who fear Him, and He delivers them. -Psalm 34:7 | | Back to Top | | |
 |  shell Registered Member
 Date Joined Mar 2002 Total Posts : 280 | Posted 5/23/2003 12:49 PM (GMT -6) |   | Tigress, I appreciate your input and I like your analogy.
thanks, Shell
| | Back to Top | | |
 |  John Earp Registered Member
 Date Joined Oct 2002 Total Posts : 1715 | Posted 5/23/2003 5:18 PM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
Luk 23:34 Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. And they parted his raiment, and cast lots.
From out here in left field, my Father looks masculine. - Me
Amen, Tim. But I don't really think we can rightly take this statement of Jesus and apply it to ourselves in all cases of offense, unless we are being martyred for our faith, perhaps. Stephen said essentially the same thing when he was being stoned to death unjustly. But to make this out to be a blanket forgiveness of all mankind would seem to teach universalism, wouldn't it?
As Jesus had no problem rebuking willful conscious sin when necessary, it seems to me that Jesus was saying that these people did not realize the magnitude nor the true nature of their crime. But the fact remains that Jesus didn't just say this prayer every time he was sinned against. In fact, he spoke of one particular sin that the Pharisees committed that was not possible to be forgiven.
"The Discovery of new truth will modify old views and opinions, and there is perhaps no end to this process with finite minds in any world." Charles G. Finney, Systematic Theology.
revivaltheology.net
Edited by - John Earp on 05/23/2003 10:39:47 PM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  John Earp Registered Member
 Date Joined Oct 2002 Total Posts : 1715 | Posted 5/23/2003 5:23 PM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
quote:
But that by no means means we should nurse a grudge, not at all. A grudge, as I understand it, has more to do with the emotional response we have to a person. In effect we focus anger and resentment on someone we feel has hurt us. I submit that the attitude underlying these emotions is what is wrong, not the emotions per se, the attitude of desiring to get even or at least for them to "get what's coming to them."
I appreciate your response John and I'm still digesting it...I was half asleep last night when I posted my question and I still feel half asleep this morning so I won't go too much into it right now...but I have a question here about what John said above. So if I wouldn't MIND if this guy had to serve some time in jail for his lying, cheating and destructive ways that now recently involve much bigger consequences (and this could be a reality),and if I feel that at some point it would be good for him to sit in a small cell and think about what he's done to his life and others...is that unforgiveness?
Hi shell,
My answer would be no--what you are describing is simply a desire for justice.
For example, if a man commits murder and later repents and turns to the Lord, though with respect to God his sins have been forgiven, with respect to human government he still has a penalty to pay. It is not necessarily wrong to desire justice. Many of the Psalms were a pleading with God for vindication.
That said, I certainly think it could be easy to confuse a sense of justice with feelings of hatred, malice, wrath, and vengeance, though. It seems to me that those attitudes (hatred, etc.) should not be allowed to persist in our minds as Christians.
"The Discovery of new truth will modify old views and opinions, and there is perhaps no end to this process with finite minds in any world." Charles G. Finney, Systematic Theology.
revivaltheology.net
Edited by - John Earp on 05/23/2003 10:36:33 PM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  John Earp Registered Member
 Date Joined Oct 2002 Total Posts : 1715 | Posted 5/23/2003 5:29 PM (GMT -6) |   | quote:
Also, another question. Since I do still have such strong feelings towards this guy...and he continues in his pattern of lying, cheating and destruction, and I know this, do I have an ethical responsiblity to inform a friend that he is lying to them?
Definitely. Who's more important, your friends who are being mistreated or this jerk who apparently has no conscience? What if the guy was a serial date-rapist who also claimed to be a minister of God? Would it be by definition "unloving" to expose him to the proper authorities? Had the Roman Catholic hierarchy taken a strong moral stand against evil within its own ranks, many, many children would perhaps have escaped the torment of sexual molestation.
quote:
But...is this because of my emotions towards this guy...is it desiring payback...to be honest I don't know? I just can't stand the thought that he is lying to one of my best friends.
Again, I think (and I could certainly be wrong) that what you are describing is not wrong--to want to protect your apparently quite deceived friends.
quote: Is it gossip to share with this close friend that they are being lied to and misled because it damages the reputation of the one doing the lying?
He's damaging his own reputation; you are not damaging it, HE is. Again, if your motive is to protect your friends from someone who is apparently an emotional predator, it does not seem clear how it is wrong to warn your friends.
Jesus, Paul, John, Peter, and most all of the New Testament writers had no problem pointing out liars, cheats, swindlers, charlatans, and the like. I think this crisis of indecision you find yourself in really simply has to do with the greatly mistaken idea, so common in our society in general, that love = being "nice."
"The Discovery of new truth will modify old views and opinions, and there is perhaps no end to this process with finite minds in any world." Charles G. Finney, Systematic Theology.
revivaltheology.net
Edited by - John Earp on 05/23/2003 10:32:45 PM | | Back to Top | | |
| Forum Information | Currently it is Monday, November 09, 2026 2:58 PM (GMT -6) There are a total of 97,718 posts in 6,040 threads. In the last 3 days there were 0 new threads and 0 reply posts. View Active Threads
|
Forum powered by dotNetBB v2.42EC SP3 dotNetBB © 2000-2026 |
|
|