 |
|  honorman Registered Member
 Date Joined Oct 2002 Total Posts : 1137 | Posted 4/9/2003 6:09 AM (GMT -6) |   | With the toppling of the statue in Bagdad I would just like to offer a praise of thanks to the God who opposes evil and thank him for the liberation of the Iraq people from the one who caused them such sorrow. May God guide our country in the days ahead as we try to do what is right and just. To God be the glory...he has done great things with our country...
| | Back to Top | | |
 |  Magneton Registered Member
 Date Joined Aug 2001 Total Posts : 132 | Posted 4/10/2003 6:40 AM (GMT -6) |   | The scenes of celebrating Iraqis, kissing American soldiers and singing the praises of America and President Bush, are very amazing. The understandably startled reactions from the Arab world are also very interesting. Their eyes are being opened to the reality of Saddam's oppression.
It reminds me that there is nothing more convincing than "the song of the soul set free." While good preaching and teaching is of great value, the testimony of a person delivered from the consequences of a life without God is more compelling. Just as cynicism and mistrust prevent many from accepting America's account of current events, the joy of the redeemed can be the most powerful apologetic.
Magneton
"Only those who will risk going too far can possibly find out how far one can go." - T. S. Eliot | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Electra Registered Member

Date Joined Feb 2002 Total Posts : 611 | Posted 4/10/2003 10:54 AM (GMT -6) |   | quote: It reminds me that there is nothing more convincing than "the song of the soul set free." While good preaching and teaching is of great value, the testimony of a person delivered from the consequences of a life without God is more compelling. Just as cynicism and mistrust prevent many from accepting America's account of current events, the joy of the redeemed can be the most powerful apologetic.
Can you clarify what you mean by these statements? How is the destruction of Saddam Hussein’s regime via our invasion like/unlike deliverance from life without God? And how is the joy over this like/unlike the joy of the redeemed? Maybe they are just cynical but it seems like there is more substance (e.g. historical experience of American foreign policy in the Arab region and an enormous imbalance of power) to some Arab’s hesitancy to trust America.
Electra
Love in action is a harsh and dreadful thing. ~ Dostoevsky | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Electra Registered Member

Date Joined Feb 2002 Total Posts : 611 | Posted 4/10/2003 1:36 PM (GMT -6) |   | Many Arab people share Iraq’s gratitude toward the US for defeating Sadam Hussein’s tyrannous regime. But here are some things Arab newspapers are reporting about the US after the fall of Baghdad.
quote: We tell the Iraqi people: Rejoice after Saddam Hussein is gone, despite the fact that we know very well, and they know as well, that from now on they will be under a US wing that is ever in the ascendant. El Khabar -Algeria
Can the destruction of Saddam Hussein's statue... give international legitimacy to a war whose beginning was not clean? Yes, we Arabs deserve what is happening to us... but this is too much for us. Al-Jamahiriyah – Libya
It is wrong for the US to use its military muscle and hardware, which was designed for its counterparts in military power, against a small country like Iraq. Al-Quds - Palestinian
This loathsome war against Iraq is a war in which more bombs and weapons of destruction have been used than before in the history of mankind. It is a war against the Arabs. It is first a war against Arab honour and second a war to change the geographical map of the Arab nation. Al-Arab al-Alamiyah - London
The aggression against Iraq is a violation of international legitimacy and a serious threat to Arab national security. Al-Thawrah - Syria
The hidden agenda of the aggressors against Iraq - as well as the deception of the world community with empty slogans calling for the liberation of Iraq, the dissemination of democracy and subsequent reconstruction - has begun to unravel. Al-Wafd - Egypt
Baghdad fell yesterday to the hands of the new Tartars just as it fell to Hulaku [Khan] in 1258 [AD]. This momentous event will have great ramifications for the whole region. Free people should not go to sleep while there is inequity or accept occupation. Al-Watan - Oman
The USA has declared war on Islam. The USA has perpetrated the worst terrorist crimes against Muslims in Iraq and Palestine. Al-Watan – Qatar
It only took us a few weeks to destroy Sadam Hussein’s regime. But the Iraqis have earned honor for the liberation of their people over the last three decades in which thousands and thousands of Iraqis have sacrificed their lives for freedom from Saddam Hussein and his regime. As Iraqi people struggle with the tension between relief that Sadam Hussein is gone and humiliation at being invaded by America, we can help by treating them with honor. We can share their grief and express our gratitude toward them for the sacrifices many of them have made for freedom, if for no other reason than our growing awareness of the effects the security of their nation can have on our own. Empowering people with the dignity they deserve rather than with weapons whenever doing so suits our interests is a defense against terrorism that should be taken seriously.
Love in action is a harsh and dreadful thing. ~ Dostoevsky | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Magneton Registered Member
 Date Joined Aug 2001 Total Posts : 132 | Posted 4/10/2003 4:26 PM (GMT -6) |   | Electra, The parallel I see is that preachers and teachers of the gospel have a credibility problem in the world, and this is not without justification. America also has a credibility problem in the world, and this is not without justification.
The fact that the Iraqi people were oppressed by an evil dictator is only now becoming apparent to some in the Arab world. It is the testimony of the Iraqi people that is convincing them, not the words coming from America. Similarly, the testimonies of those delivered from the bondage of the evil one can be more powerful than the words coming from preachers and teachers of the gospel.
I didn’t intend to draw any parallels between the processes involved, nor to make a case for the rightness of America’s methods in this case.
Magneton
Only the mind cannot be sent into exile. Ovid | | Back to Top | | |
 |  honorman Registered Member
 Date Joined Oct 2002 Total Posts : 1137 | Posted 4/10/2003 5:29 PM (GMT -6) |   | Think allegory, not all comparsion have to be taken literally. Take the opinions of Arab papers that are predominantly anti-american? I don't think so or nor do I care to. "...the humilation of being invaded by America?" What a bunch of cr-p?! Where do you get such clueless statements? Instead of reading anti-american propaganda why don't you view the scenes coming over the airwaves about what is really going on. You really need to get out more...
All those celebrating Iraq's must have gotten over their humilation pretty darn quick 
Edited by - honorman on 04/10/2003 10:30:58 PM | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/10/2003 6:42 PM (GMT -6) |   | Electra said: quote: It only took us a few weeks to destroy Sadam Hussein’s regime. But the Iraqis have earned honor for the liberation of their people over the last three decades in which thousands and thousands of Iraqis have sacrificed their lives for freedom from Saddam Hussein and his regime. As Iraqi people struggle with the tension between relief that Sadam Hussein is gone and humiliation at being invaded by America, we can help by treating them with honor. We can share their grief and express our gratitude toward them for the sacrifices many of them have made for freedom, if for no other reason than our growing awareness of the effects the security of their nation can have on our own. Empowering people with the dignity they deserve rather than with weapons whenever doing so suits our interests is a defense against terrorism that should be taken seriously.
I'm both befuddled and somewhat offended by the tone that you have taken here, Electra.
Befuddled because you concede that we should be concerned that the security of Iraq affects our own national security, yet in the same breath you decry that we have chosen to act on that concern.
Befuddled because you demand that we "empower" the Iraqi people, but decry the fact that we are in the process of doing it.
Offended at your implication that those who have been in favor of using military force in this endeavor, and are now rejoicing at the sight of renewed Iraqi freedom, are somehow less interested than you are in "treating [the Iraqi people] with honor."

Brett
"Siste viator et memento mori." | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/10/2003 6:45 PM (GMT -6) |   | Here's a point of view from an Iraqi that I heard on NPR this morning. You can listen to it here.
Brett
"Siste viator et memento mori." | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Electra Registered Member

Date Joined Feb 2002 Total Posts : 611 | Posted 4/11/2003 4:09 AM (GMT -6) |   | quote: Electra said: quote: It only took us a few weeks to destroy Sadam Hussein’s regime. But the Iraqis have earned honor for the liberation of their people over the last three decades in which thousands and thousands of Iraqis have sacrificed their lives for freedom from Saddam Hussein and his regime. As Iraqi people struggle with the tension between relief that Sadam Hussein is gone and humiliation at being invaded by America, we can help by treating them with honor. We can share their grief and express our gratitude toward them for the sacrifices many of them have made for freedom, if for no other reason than our growing awareness of the effects the security of their nation can have on our own. Empowering people with the dignity they deserve rather than with weapons whenever doing so suits our interests is a defense against terrorism that should be taken seriously.
I'm both befuddled and somewhat offended by the tone that you have taken here, Electra.
Befuddled because you concede that we should be concerned that the security of Iraq affects our own national security, yet in the same breath you decry that we have chosen to act on that concern.
Befuddled because you demand that we "empower" the Iraqi people, but decry the fact that we are in the process of doing it.
Offended at your implication that those who have been in favor of using military force in this endeavor, and are now rejoicing at the sight of renewed Iraqi freedom, are somehow less interested than you are in "treating [the Iraqi people] with honor."

Brett
I’m surprised that my statements above are causing offense. That was not my intention. I am honestly trying to be conciliatory. Whatever. Though I have argued against invasion as the most effective means of creating security, I have never denied that our own security is wrapped up with the security of the Iraqi people. The fact that I have argued against invasion is not the same as accusing you or anyone else of not caring about the suffering of Iraqi people. Since I trust that our motives behind invading Iraq were about liberating the people from Saddam Hussein (I have been accused many times of suspecting oil was the real motive, but I have never argued this), I assumed that suggestions of further ways we can empower Iraqis now that Hussein’s regime is defeated would be welcomed. What is offensive about honoring them for their suffering and struggle for freedom? I suggested this not because I assume it had not occurred to you or anyone else, but rather because I assume you care.
Love in action is a harsh and dreadful thing. ~ Dostoevsky | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/11/2003 4:33 AM (GMT -6) |   | Electra: quote: I assumed that suggestions of further ways we can empower Iraqis now that Hussein’s regime is defeated would be welcomed. What is offensive about honoring them for their suffering and struggle for freedom?
Again, I am not offended by your notion that we should "honor [the Iraqi people] for their suffering and struggle for freedom."
I am offended that you continue to suggest it.
Brett
"Siste viator et memento mori." | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/11/2003 6:06 AM (GMT -6) |   | | | |
 |  BBBCanada Registered Member

Date Joined Jun 2001 Total Posts : 2763 | Posted 4/11/2003 6:29 AM (GMT -6) |   | quote: "...the humilation of being invaded by America?" What a bunch of cr-p?! Where do you get such clueless statements?
and
You really need to get out more...
honordaddy,
Listen. You can disagree without the pejorative remarks or do you know how to do that? It's been how long? EVERYONE here knows you have a problem with this.
Go let some steam off some other way. Hit a punching bag or kick a dog or sum'n, but geeze...ugh...note the way Brett disagreed to the SAME quote. Learn from the Master. 
Brandon "Mommy, I know now that the terms, 'I'll knock yo' teeth down yo' throat!' meant you'd love me in the special way you do everyday of my life."--Darwin Hobbs www.darwinhobbs.com | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/11/2003 6:44 AM (GMT -6) |   | I'm certainly no Master, but Brandon is right about your mean-spiritedness, HonorDad. Just shootin' straight with you. Many times I will see something you write that I agree with, but it is couched in such vicious language that I can't come out and support you for fear of being misconstrued. I'm telling you, even the people that you may disagree with 99% of the time on this board are typically wonderful Christians who have the same good intentions that we all try to have. I know debate can sometimes bring out the emotion in all of us (myself certainly included), but shouldn't we maintain a healthy level of love and respect for each other? Agree?
Brett
"Siste viator et memento mori." | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Electra Registered Member

Date Joined Feb 2002 Total Posts : 611 | Posted 4/11/2003 6:45 AM (GMT -6) |   | quote: Again, I am not offended by your notion that we should "honor [the Iraqi people] for their suffering and struggle for freedom."
I am offended that you continue to suggest it.
In what sense is my suggestion continual, and why does that make it offensive to you? Many suggestions are being made for ways to express our care for Iraqis and many of them are being made repeatedly. Are you also offended by continual suggestions that we join the Iraqi people in celebrating the defeat of Sadam Hussein's regime?
My suggestion is not intended to be exclusive (i.e. this is the only appropriate way to show care) or superior (this is the best way to show care), or implicitly indicting (if you really cared, this is what you would do). To whatever extent I am sending you messages like this, I apologize. I will try to better express my respect for our mutual care and concern over the situation in Iraq when I share my reflections on this issue.
Love in action is a harsh and dreadful thing. ~ Dostoevsky | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/11/2003 7:19 AM (GMT -6) |   | Okay, I don't want to take this too far, because in the end, I know you aren't purposefully trying to offend me or anyone. However, I get the sense from your recent posts that you consider those advocating military action and rejoicing in its success to be somehow less concerned about the honor and dignity of the Iraqi people than you are.
To be specific, after HonorDad and Magneton began this thread with celebrations of Iraqi freedom, you felt the need to tell them that they should be concerned with "[e]mpowering people with the dignity they deserve rather than with weapons whenever doing so suits our interests...." I don't know how else to take this, Electra, except that those in favor of using "weapons" are uninterested in "empowering people with the dignity they deserve." I hope you can understand why some might take offense at the sanctimonious nature of that remark.
Further, when I pointed out that the remark was offensive, you responded with this question: "What is offensive about honoring [the Iraqi people] for their suffering and struggle for freedom?" In other words, you suggest yet again that what I found offensive was your desire to honor the Iraqi people for their suffering and struggle.
Do you see my point?
Brett
"Siste viator et memento mori." | | Back to Top | | |
 |  Electra Registered Member

Date Joined Feb 2002 Total Posts : 611 | Posted 4/11/2003 8:21 AM (GMT -6) |   | Brett: Okay, I don't want to take this too far, because in the end, I know you aren't purposefully trying to offend me or anyone. However, I get the sense from your recent posts that you consider those advocating military action and rejoicing in its success to be somehow less concerned about the honor and dignity of the Iraqi people than you are.
Electra: I have argued that invasion is not the best way to express our care for Iraqi people, but I am not interested in arguing about who cares about them most. I know this is offensive and frustrating, because some have suggested that if I really cared about Iraqis, I would support the invasion. Again, I am sorry if my recent posts have been in that category. That is not my intention to suggest such an indictment of motives.
Brett: To be specific, after HonorDad and Magneton began this thread with celebrations of Iraqi freedom, you felt the need to tell them that they should be concerned with "[e]mpowering people with the dignity they deserve rather than with weapons whenever doing so suits our interests...." I don't know how else to take this, Electra, except that those in favor of using "weapons" are uninterested in "empowering people with the dignity they deserve." I hope you can understand why some might take offense at the sanctimonious nature of that remark.
Electra: I did not intend these comments to be direct responses to either honordad or Magneton's celebration of Iraqi freedom. They are my own reflections on the situation, that I do not wish to imply are over and against others' celebrations, which I should have more explicitly affirmed. Most agree that the US has made some mistakes in its past foreign policy that will hopefully not be repeated in the future—such as supplying weapons to Sadam Hussein. I should have specified that empowering free people with dignity vs. weapons was not a reference to invasion, but rather to the consensus about bad foreign policy decisions in the past.
Brett: Further, when I pointed out that the remark was offensive, you responded with this question: "What is offensive about honoring [the Iraqi people] for their suffering and struggle for freedom?" In other words, you suggest yet again that what I found offensive was your desire to honor the Iraqi people for their suffering and struggle.
Electra: I would not appeal to our desire to help Iraqi people if I didn't believe anyone cared. I thought that this presupposition was clear, and that is why I was surprised that you took offense. I can see now how my question re-offended you. Instead of presupposing our good intentions toward them, I should have been explicit about my trust in the sincerity of the devotion to the Iraqi cause for liberation. Again, I apologize.
As honordad, Magneton, you, and I have noted on this thread, many Arab people share Iraq’s gratitude toward the US for defeating Sadam Hussein’s tyrannous regime. As we explore and discuss the complex responses to the situation in Iraq, I will try to do so in ways that explicitly affirm our mutual care and concern for the people rather than sanctimoniously insinuating that I care any more than anyone else.
Love in action is a harsh and dreadful thing. ~ Dostoevsky | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/11/2003 10:24 AM (GMT -6) |   | You are a gentle[wo]man and a scholar, Electra. Sorry for misconstruing your point, and I so appreciate your willingness to find common ground on tough issues. I hope my differences with you (which are rare, by the way!) never overshadow my fundamental respect and admiration for your spirit, intelligence, and wisdom.
Blessings and thanks,
Brett
"Siste viator et memento mori." | | Back to Top | | |
 |  BJS Registered Member
 Date Joined Dec 2001 Total Posts : 587 | Posted 4/12/2003 7:02 PM (GMT -6) |   | | | |
| Forum Information | Currently it is Monday, November 09, 2026 1:42 PM (GMT -6) There are a total of 97,718 posts in 6,040 threads. In the last 3 days there were 0 new threads and 0 reply posts. View Active Threads
|
Forum powered by dotNetBB v2.42EC SP3 dotNetBB © 2000-2026 |
|
|